FICTION IN POETRY
I've been pondering the POV expressed in class about the
C. K. Williams poem, that it MUST somehow be true, although
my entire THESIS, especially for those who have had
me more than once, is that the poet uses a persona that
IS NOT THE POET, although in essence there is an element
of the autobiographical in place. But then I think of, say,
Frank Bidart's highly admired "Herbert White," a poem I've
taught numerous times. Anyway, all things being equal,
I'm curious as to why we can accept a book like Silence of the
Lambs (I'm pretty sure no one has arrested Thomas Harris
for his fictional creation) and not assume that author had to
commit the murders portrayed there in order to write about them.
I mean, Harris must have really wanted a Hannibal Lecter
type to be living amongst us--he survives to kill again and again . . .
And of course we know that is not the case. We give LICENSE . . .
It's the same thing--the poet chooses a POV character
that is far far from the norm and speaks from it in order
to broaden perspectives. Williams uses--here comes a far-out
concept--a thing called THE IMAGINATION. This is what
Norman Dubie does pretty much in every poem he writes. This is
what the director does in the film Henry Fool. Anyway, the
assumption that somehow a poet can't use similar fictions (as
novelists and filmmakers do) to explore the dark side of the world,
or that which is at first glance somehow SHOCKING, is one of
poetry's great potentials and one of its great problems
right now (still!! In 2010!). Poems are not little memoirs of precious
FACT. And yet poems remain open to extreme prejudice. I'm trying
to argue to give poets the same right to explore subject matter,
however uncomfortable it might make a reader, other artists
have access too without causing us the blink of an eye.
In essence, an artist can't write or express views about a subject
without having experienced it? Really? REALLY?
I must say it was a bit depressing to run into that old,
antiquated attitude--I thought it had mostly disappeared in
these here parts . . .
***
Okay, well here's simply a good poem from class, posted below.
My Father –
McKenzie Sanders
Today, my father said
he went out to get batteries
for the remote control
helicopter I bought him
for Christmas.
Too bad he forgot that was the gift
for my brother.
He went out of the room,
slamming the doors
behind him –
“went there”
a year and a half ago
tomorrow.
The immigration office
said, if they don’t take
the car back, you can just
cancel the insurance and
return the plates and
sell it back for –
My father would have been
a great consultant.
But he had no choice
but to go back home.
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Well I can only speak for myself and since this seems to be aimed mostly at me since I am the one who mostly spoke up in class about this, this is my response to the above comments.
ReplyDeleteYou stated that the poem was fiction, and I simply asked how do you really know that?
I really don’t think a reader knows either way for sure, unless the writer tells them and the writer is truthful. Poets are not exempt from ills of society and we can’t assume their words are a persona any more than we can assume that it is non-fictional.
Can a poet be a pedophile and write about it, yes. Can a poet not be a pedophile and write about it, yes. In the end it really isn’t important to the poem.
I believe poets can write about anything they want, whether using a persona or not. But we can't assume just because the poem is about a dark subject (pedophile behaviors for example) that it is not true or simply a persona,nor is it right to assume it is true story.
Poets are just like anyone else in the terms of life experiences, feelings, their imagination,their personal activities, moral and immoral. In the end, it is only the poem that counts.
It's of value to ponder. Examining assumptions is important. I think the poem,
ReplyDeletewhich isn't even about an act at all but is
only about THINKING SOMETHING (and therefore is
the same as dreaming something) is brilliant
in that it forces us to wonder about our own
reactions in the face of what simply amounts
to an abstract thought. Is anyone who has ever simply thought a thing in substance
the VALUE of that thought, moral or otherwise?
I guess it's true, sure, we don't KNOW that Thomas Harris hasn't committed murder and then eaten the corpses, but I'm pretty sure most
movie buffs didn't have to wrestle with that suspicion while watching the film, and I think
culturally there is this IDEA that poets are
somehow almost doomed to be truthtellers--which should (and is) actually, good (we should
never be afraid of the truth as it is presented in ideas, etc)--only too many people
can't separate thought from action. The poem
actually is very brilliant in the way it uses
the subject in such a way that a person could somehow jump to the idea of the act it IMAGINES
as having taken place. When it is clear from the text that it is only about not freaking out
over simply THINKING of a thing. I suppose I'd say we have to try to trust that a writer we like, if he or she goes somewhere scary, isn't in fact the monster that might be depicted on the page. I do have to say that my opinion of Williams is aided by my knowledge
that he is basically a writer whose subject IS morality, and so he's frequently depicting
characters etc to represent his ideas on morality and prjudice, etc. My passion here
only really has to do with giving poets the same license we give other writers and artists.
You are right that it is only the poem that counts, and so it's worthwhile to have the discussion.